Sunday, March 12, 2017

Interpreting The Third Verse Of Joni Mitchell's Little Green



Massive (fun) argument today with my daughter Lainie on this verse from Little Green, third track on Joni Mitchell's Blue:


...He went to California
Hearing that everything's warmeru there
So you write him a letter, say, "her eyes are blue"
He sends you a poem and she's lost to you
Little, green, he's a non-comformer...


My reading: she gives up her daughter due the call of art.


Hers: she loses her daughter when her daughter's father won't support his daughter, responding to a plea for his help--"her eyes are blue"--with something unrelated and non responsive--"He sends you a poem"--which makes her understand no help is coming and she can't raise her daughter alone.


My further thought: Maybe the two views merge in this: if she weren't personally sacrificing so much for her art she could get a normal job and raise her child as a single mother. But the thing she can't do is all three of: pursue her art; work ow when she has to; and raise her daughter alone. So she gives up her daughter for adoption. And what does she do right after: she continues pursuing her art. In that how different is she than the kid's father.


All the lyrics:


Born with the moon in Cancer
Choose her a name she'll answer too
Call her green and the winters can not fade her
Call her green for the children who have made her little, green
Be a gypsy dancer


He went to California
Hearing that everything's warmer there
So you write him a letter, say, "her eyes are blue"
He sends you a poem and she's lost to you
Little, green, he's a non-comformer


Just a little green
Like the color when the spring is born
There'll be crocuses to bring to school tomorrow
Just a little green
Like the night's when the Northern lights perform
There'll be icicles and birthday clothes and sometimes
There'll be sorrow


Child with a child pretending
Weary of lies you're sending home
So you sign all the papers in the family name
You're sad and you're sorry but you're not ashamed, little green
Have a happy ending


Just a little green
Like the color when the spring is born
There'll be crocuses to bring to school tomorrow
Just a little green
Like the night's when the Northern lights perform
There'll be icicles and birthday clothes
And sometimes there'll be sorrow


The song as sung: 


https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=ZQzMt0M8fRc

Thursday, March 9, 2017

The Franklin's Tale As Resolving The Theme Of Marriage


3/10/17

I may offer a note or three on a thought or three on a few of the Tales.

The Frankiln's Tale as resolving the theme of marriage: 

As I read The Franklin's Tale it resolves the extreme positions on the relations between men and women in marriage taken in the related tales: who shall have sovereignty, who shall be compliant to whom and who shall endure suffering and if so how much, how to act properly and so on. 

Nobility of spirit fills the tale and breathes life into the themes of love, honor, sacrifice, fidelity to truth, promise keeping and the expansiveness of compassion as at the core of an unconventional ideal of love as manifest in ideal marriage. 

Arveragus rejects the idea of Walter from the Clerk's Tale. He doesn't expect, assert or impose sovereignty over his wife. And in kind Dorigen rejects "Bathism." She vows constancy and mutuality of obedience in return for his abdication of his conventional husband's superiority in marriage. The Franklin says that in this reciprocality is ground of true marriage happiness. 

The crux of the tale is Dorigen's unserious promise to Aurelius to be with him if he removes the stones from the shore, which the magician for 1,000 pounds appears to accomplish. She is caught between the honor of keeping her unmeant, flippant  promise and her constancy to her husband. 

She asks Arveragus what he would have her do. But he asserts no authority over her. He respects her autonomy and her honor. In advising her to commit adultery he will not as such be cheated on; nor will his wife be inconstant as such. In consenting to her fulfilling her promise, he vindicates at his own expense her personal autonomy evident in her promise keeping. 

When she meets Aurelius and explains the considerations and forbearances that she and her husband have undergone in finally having her come to him in this dilemma-wracked situation, he, in a moment of nobility and compassion is moved by the nobility of both Averagus and Dorigen. Out of compassion Aurelius releases her from her covenant to him. 

(Updated version, even though Chaucer's poetry is so much better) 

Aurelius then gave this matter thought,
As in his heart he had such great compassion               
For Dorigen, lamenting in this fashion,
And for Arveragus, this worthy knight
Who bade that she be faithful to her plight,
So loath to see his wife break any vow.
And in his heart he had great pity now;                    
Looking for what was best from every side,
He'd rather leave his lust unsatisfied
Than do this churlish deed, so wretchedly
To act against such fine nobility;
These were the few words of Aurelius:

 "Now, Madam, tell your lord Arveragus
That since I see this man's great nobleness
Toward you, and I see, too, your distress,
That rather he'd have shame--sad that would be--
Than have you break the vow you made to me,                
I'd rather suffer woe my whole life through
Than to divide the love between you two.
So, madam, I release you here and now,
Returning to your hand each oath and vow
That you have ever made to me or sworn                     
Back to the very day that you were born.
I pledge my word, you I will never grieve
For any promise. Here I take my leave,
And of the truest and most perfect wife
That I have ever met in all my life."                      
In what you promise, every wife, take care!
At least remember Dorigen, beware.

As I see it, Arveragus affirms Dorigen as his equal and affirms her integrity in keeping her promise to Aurelius. As an equal, her promise binds her as much any he may give and be honor bound to keep. His love for his wife entails his own painful selflessness as does hers for him.

Finally, the ethic of compassion is ever expanding. When Aurelius recounts these events to the magician, to whom , as noted, he's indebted for 1,000 pounds for making the stones off the shoreline appear to disappear, the magician is moved to forgive this debt both out of his own compassion and as affected by the virtuous examples set.

Monday, March 6, 2017

A Suggested Reading Of Chaucer's The Clerk's Tale

3/6/17

The Clerk's Tale 

I'm now reading the Merchant's Tale but I'm having trouble getting The Clerk's Tale out of my mind for its portrayal of sheer evil--the notion of existential evil occurs to me--in Walter's depthless tormented testing of Griselda, who, stretching all credibility  beyond any conceivable breaking point even when allowing for presentism, dutifully and lovingly takes it all and accepts it all. Why the exaggerated-to-the-point-of-disbelief abhorrent cruelty--the murder of her children as he has her believe; and why the beyond-belief docile and self abnegating acceptance of it all by Griselda? Is it all rescued and set aright by the Clerk's final editorial ameliorating words at tale's end--wives be not so meek and submissive but as well be constant in adversity? 

I think not. 

What I think is that the tale, apart from the usual noted contrasts in the treatment of marriage with the other tales, is radically subversive and subsumes too the Clerk's final moderating advice. To my mind, the radical subversion works in at least three ways: 

first, it savagely pummels into wretched absurdity the roles and conduct men and women were conventionally held to at the time; 

second, in a parallel way it explodes the literary forms, conventions and precedents that conveyed these conventions. It does so by stretching the tale first into sheer unbelievability in the cruelty and its acceptance, and second having that incredibility  make ridiculous in its insufficiency the temporizing final advice that platitudinously counsels, as noted, a balancing of less humility than Griselda with constancy in adversity. 

The Clerk says his story isn't a model for wives to follow Griselda in humility but that everyone ought to be constant in adversity. In that, the moral is discordant with the exemplum. And, is there scriptural allegory involved; might there be echoes in Griselda of the story of Mary? But if Griselda echoes Mary, what does that make Walter? He seems, to put it in modern terms, a case study in existential evil, evil, that is to say, which exists for its own sake and satisfaction but is dressed up in the tale as mere testing conduct;

and third, in the way (say) of black humour, the reader who follows the story uncritically and is satisfied by and accepts the Clerk's final platitudes of advice as resolving everything is made the unthinking fool in the way that those who laugh at the horror and cruelty of black humour become in a way complicit at what arouses their laughter.

Listen, what I know about Chaucer scholarship and criticism wouldn't fill a small thimble. I don't whether anything like my reading of the Clerk's Tale has ever been proposed. But the way I'm seeing it, especially with Chaucer appearing to be in the "devil's camp" with the Wife of Bath, the way it's said Milton is with Satan, is the only was I can make sense of it.

Saturday, February 25, 2017

Long Lost By Harlan Coben



SUMMARY not written by me. 



A WOMEN NAMED TERESE COLLINS, CALLS A MAN BY THE NAME OF MYRON BOLITAR. SHE TELLS HIM TO LEAVE NEW JERSEY AND TO COME TO PARIS. MYRON GIVES UP ON A LOCAL GAL WHO WAS GOING TO BREAK IT OFF WITH HIM ANYWAYS, AND ACCEPTS TERESE'S INVITATION. AFTER ARRIVING, MYRON LEARNS THAT TERESE CAME TO PARIS BECAUSE OF HER EX-HUSBAND, RICK COLLINS, WHO WAS DESPERATE TO SEE HER BUT WOULD NOT SAY WHY ON THE PHONE. ON HER ARRIVAL IN PARIS, RICK COULD NOT BE LOCATED. SO TERESE CALLS ON HER OLD BOYFRIEND, MYRON, WHOM SHE KNOWS IS VERY GOOD AT FINDING PEOPLE. COPS IN PARIS SHOW UP TO INVESTIGATE THEM AND MYRON LEARNS RICK HAS BEEN MURDERED. THE COPS SUSPECT TERESE. BLOOD AT THE MURDER SCENE PROVES TO BE THAT OF RICK AND THEY FIND DNA THAT REVEALS BLOOD WAS THERE THAT WAS SIMILAR ENOUGH TO RICK'S TO BE THAT OF A YOUNG GIRL, AS IF A DAUGHTER. THE COPS RESUME LOOKING FOR BOTH, AND TERESE THINKS OF HOW SHE LOST THE ONLY CHILD THEY HAD TOGETHER, IN A CAR CRASH YEARS EARLIER. MYRON AND TERESE ARE THEN RELEASED UPON GIVING UP THEIR PASSPORTS. MYRON GOES FOR A WALK ALONE AFTER, AND FIND TWO MEN TRYING TO KIDNAP HIM. MYRON RESISTS AND TAKES THE GUN FROM ONE, SHOOTING HIM, WHILE LETTING THE OTHER ESCAPE. POLICE COME TO ARREST MYRON. HE LEARNS THAT THE ONE HE SHOT IS IN THE HOSPITAL, AND THE ONE THAT ESCAPED LEFT IN A VAN WITH A TEEN WHO HAS LONG BLONDE HAIR. THIS TEEN WAS THOUGHT TO BE TERESE'S AND RICKS SUPPOSEDLY DECEASED DAUGHTER. NOW TERESE IS GONE. MYRON'S WEALTHY PAL, WIN LOCKWOOD, FLIES HIS JET TO PARIS SO HE CAN HELP MYRON. LOCKWOOD DOES HIS OWN INVESTIGATION AND LOCATES TERESE ON HIS OWN. SHE BOARDS THE JET AND SOON MYRON ARRIVES. WIN TELLS MYRON THAT HE FOUND OUT MYRON'S VICTIM DIED IN THE HOSPITAL, AND THE COPS WANT MYRON FOR MURDER. NOW TERESE LEARNS THAT HER DAUGHTER MIGHT HAVE SURVIVED THE CRASH THAT HAPPENED 10 YEARS EARLIER. MYRON THEN HAS A RETIRED COP WHO INVESTIGATED THE CAR CRASH, HELP THEM. TERESE THEN WANTS TO GO TO HER DAUGHTERS GRAVE AND DIG UP THE BODY. NEXT THEY TALK TO RICK'S WIDOW, AND LEARN NOTHING. BUT THIS IS NOTICED AND MYRON SEES HE'S BEING FOLLOWED. SO IT'S LEARNED THAT SOMEONE MYRON AND TERESE EARLIER QUESTIONED, WAS LATER FOUND MURDERED. THEN WITH A CONFRONTATION AND ALTERCATION WITH THE KIDNAPPERS, RICK'S WIDOW WAS KILLED. THEY ALSO SHOT MYRON AND TERESE, BUT DID NOT KILL THEM. MYRON AND TERESE ACTUALLY KILLED THE KIDNAPPERS. IT WAS REPORTED IN THE NEWSPAPER THAT RICK, AN INVESTIGATIVE REPORTER, WAS INFILTRATING A TERRORIST GROUP WHEN HE WAS KILLED. ALSO, THE PAPER SAYS SPECIAL FORCES KILLED THE TERRORIST GROUP, SO NOW THE MEMBERS OF THE GROUP WOULD NOT BE SEEKING MYRON OR WIN. MYRON WAS THEN TAKEN BY THEM ANYWAYS, AND REMAINED UNCONSCIOUS FOR TWO WEEKS. TERESE SURVIVED THE GUNSHOT WOUND ONLY TO LEARN THAT HER DAUGHTER WAS INDEED KILLED IN THE CAR CRASH YEARS AGO. WHEN RICK AND TERESE WERE TRYING TO GET PREGNANT, THEY TRIED FREEZING THE EMBRYO UNTIL AN ADVANCE IN SCIENCE COULD HELP. THEY DID NOT KNOW THOUGH THAT INSTEAD OF BEING STORED, IT WAS PLACED IN A SURROGATE MOTHER. THIS EMBRYO IS NOW A 17 YEAR OLD NAMED CARRIE. THE SEARCH IS NOW ON FOR CARRIE AND THEY THINK THE TERRORIST GROUP HAS HER. THEY FIND CARRIE AT A HOME FOR UNWED MOTHERS, BUT GOING THERE IS MET WITH GUNFIRE. MYRON KILLS THE MEN FROM THE GROUP. IT TURNS OUT THE HOME FOR UNWED MOTHERS WAS USING FROZEN EMBRYOS, NOT FOR LATER ADOPTIVE PURPOSES, BUT TO RAISE A NEW GROUP OF TERRORISTS. TERESE HAD FOUND CARRIE AND TOOK HER TO A REMOTE VILLAGE THAT TERESE HAD SPENT TIME AT WHILE IN AFRICA. SHE KNEW MYRON WOULD KNOW WHERE SHE WENT. MYRON JOINS THEM IN AFRICA, AND THE BOOK ENDS THERE.        

http://longlostharlancoben.weebly.com/summary.html

Wednesday, February 22, 2017

When We Were Orphans by Kazuo Ishiguro: A Note

2/22/17

When We Were Orphans, Kazuo Ishiguro:

Spoiler-filled note:

It's highly literary and is ostensibly and subvertingly set in the frame of a typical non literary detective novel, which it partially reverses. In many less than literary detective novels, there is a tight world into which evil has anomalously intruded but is rooted out by detection and discovery that lead in turn to a closing of accounts and a return to normalcy. In When..., Banks, the main character, is a famous detective in the apparent mould of Holmes. But he fails abjectly to solve his biggest case. Then again while the world is generally hell on earth, Banks does manage to find some portion of something like normalcy.

He is famous in England and beyond for his great skills at solving cases. But when he was 10, living in the international section of Shanghai, his parents disappeared. And so on his most important case he goes back to Shanghai to solve the mystery of that, which solution seems as well, in a way never made clear, to hold the possibility of staving off a world crisis of war and international chaos. 

This coupling of the personal and the international is perplexing but it's not only Banks who puts the two together: others around him both back in England before he leaves and officials in Shanghai keep telling him that he must solve the case--the fate of the world depends on it. 

Truth to tell, in relation to that coupling and what radiates out from it as Banks starts detecting in Shanghai, I have a hard time working through what's real and what's Banks's interiority. I can understand that coupling insofar as as the world is but what he takes it to be: in that sense, the personal is the world as subjectivity. But I don't know what to make of Banks, as first person narrator, telling me of people in England telling him he must solve the case for the world's sake; and I don't know what to make of Banks telling me of high English officials in Shanghai, once he gets back there, telling him the same thing with one official talking about planning  a huge public ceremony for when he inevitably finds his parents. 

Apparently Banks knows that his parents were abducted and are being kept in a certain house and that all he need do is find the house and extract them from the kidnappers. Everyone seems to agree. But this is 25 years after the abduction. 

Is this madness? Is this reality? Is it something else? Significantly for these questions, the narration seems to be composed by Banks in his later years as he reflects back on his life;  his narrative prose generally, not always, shows a calm, understated, somewhat stiff and stuffy, even fussy, formal, Cambridge-educated, unrelentingly rational man, who appears reflective, discerning and continually making sober judgments about the events of his life.

Part of the book concerns a harrowing account of how at the last minute instead of calmly waiting to go off with Sarah Hemmings, he leaves her behind and tries to get to the house where he's sure his parents are kept. The journey to the house, amidst street to street fighting between Chinese and Japanese soldiers, and amidst Japanese shelling of Shanghai, seems a journey through and to the heart of darkness. 

At one point he picks up with a seriously wounded Japanese soldier who he recognizes as his childhood best friend Akira. Akira tells Banks he knows where the house is. And they make their way there, each helping the other along. Then Japanese soldiers, in the house, with no sign of Banks's parents anywhere, take Akira away as a prisoner who may have spilled military information to Chinese soldiers to save his own life. After that Banks admits that the soldier he was sure was Akira may not have been him at all, (although he may have been at that.)

Now this confusion over Akira makes narrative and psychological sense. In the event, the emotional strain, fatigue and existential desperation to find his parents, all almost to, or in fact to, a psychic breaking point, could well cause Banks to hallucinate this highly improbable, virtually impossible, harried, fraught encounter with his friend. As noted, Banks tells us that it may well not have been Akira. 

As to those in England and later in Shanghai, however, telling Banks the world's order rests on him solving his parents' case, and in Shanghai the planning of preparations to celebrate his inevitable solution, what to make of that? There is no indication, as there is with Akira, from Banks that he may be mistaken about being told these things. At the time of being told, he is under no apparent strain, especially when told in England. Either I'm missing something or in this the novel lapses into incomprehensibility, into incoherence. (I'd put my money on the former.)

The same lapse, incoherence, or my missing something, attends the Lin family's willingness to vacate Banks's Shanghai childhood home once Banks without doubt finds his parents. The notion that it would do that, just like that give up where it lives, is as preposterous as Banks's certainty that his parents will after 25 years be in the place they were taken, and is as preposterous as the notion that solving the case will save the world. 

Be all that as it may, When.. is thematically unified, at least as I read it. I see in it, among other ideas, the idea of the irretrievability of childhood, childhood as a country to which we can never return, even as the child is the father of the man. Everyone has their deeply burdensome built in sacks of woe stemming from their childhoods and their necessarily fraught relations with their parents. That inevitability is heightened immeasurably by orphanage. While literal orphans populate the novel, they in their numbers suggest a universal truth: that childhood, in part comprised by our relations with parents, while indelibly formative and deeply, deeply problem causing, is a home forever lost to us, that we are all orphans seeking what is lost and irretrievable. Orphanage is a literal condition to be sure, but it also a metaphoric condition of adult existence. 

Yet the title is When We Were Orphans. That suggests to me orphanage in its metaphoric sense can get gotten past, that we can come to some terms with ourselves such that we accommodate the built in burdens forged in childhood to the point that we stop intensely questing, stop detecting and discovering, to resolve them. 

So at the end, in a micro arc of the whole novel, we learn that Jennifer, 30, and unmarried, flirted with suicide, then got past her darkness, got married, had children of her own and found, presumably, some measure of contentment. Banks is released by Uncle Philip telling him the truth of things, of his parents, and is released by finding his mother, come through sheer hell to be cared for in an asylum, and her telling him, he infers, that he does not need any forgiveness and that she always loved him and still does. So released, he finds himself in his later years enjoying life in London, even as he sometimes thinks of going to live close to Jennifer and her family in a cottage in the country; so released, he has found, in his own word, some portion of "contentment." 

(As a final note, I'll just say that, to me, the idea that Banks as an adult is driven, animated and motivated by guilt over his parents' disappearance such that finding them and finding resolution in their forgiveness and love becomes his deepest, most desperate, most haunted and most impelling life's quest seems utterly unreal and contrived, as though Ishiguro was fitting a complex, sprawling story into a Procrustean bed of some half baked psychotherapeutic theory.)

Monday, February 20, 2017

Friend's Good Note On Competing Principles

...But principles are not theories; they are action guiding , and normally there are contrary principals, also action guiding, and there are no super principles for selecting principles. That is what Aristotle meant when he asserted, against Plato, that values are incommensurable (correct spelling; the computer is wrong - see OED), i.e., there is no value that is a yardstick higher than all other values that can determine which of two conflicting principles should prevail in a given situation. So, if, say, freedom/liberty are in conflict with the demand for social security in a given situation, there is no principle that can resolve the issue; a practical decision has to be made by responsible men of affairs. That is why libertarianism/free market theory is so cockeyed; it elevates individual freedom over all other social values as the yardstick by which various proposals are decided. If  the necessities of freedom are in conflict with the need for social security, freedom trumps everything, and social security loses automatically. But I reckon that Aristotle knew a thing or two more than Milton Friedman ever did, or could...

Note On Dostoyevsky's Poor Folk

2/20/17

Not So Small Note On Dostoyevsky's Poor Folk (With Spoilers)

(Well it started out as small.)

In Poor Folk, the relationship between Makar and Varvara as revealed by their letters, the way of the book, can be endlessly analyzed as can other themes, but through reading it one question kept bugging me: why doesn't he ask her to marry him? They are deeply committed to each other. They depend fully on each other in different ways at different times for material and emotional support. They profess their love for each other. They have terrible low points but are always right there for each other. 

It at first seems confusing what exactly Makar feels for Varvara: father figure, protector, brother, lover, soul mate, Platonic best friend. Why it seems confusing is not so much that he's confused but more that he cannot confront, and suppresses and sublimates, his passionate love for her. It's notable that she keeps asking him to visit her and he seems reluctant to. Even though they live across from each other and can look into each other's windows, he only seldom meets her. And what forms much, though certainly not all, of the content of their letters is their pasts, how and what each is doing, has done and how each has been affected by things not involving the other. 

Makar is febrile. He reeks of it. It seems the perfect word for him in its meanings of feverish, highly agitated, too excitable, intensely sensitive, overly nervous, highly emotional, imaginatively overactive. He is constantly driven to agitated extremes.  He is essentially a marginal man in his febrility, a low, weak laughing stock, albeit a few rungs up from an underground man. At times he questions his own existence in comparison to others. He lives in a portion of a shabby kitchen walled off by a screen and works as a "copyist." His whole existence takes meaning only in his letters to Varvara. He lives through her the way she doesn't live through him. He abases himself for her. He goes without in giving her money and things even as she tells him not to and that he oughtn't  impoverish himself for her sake. She sends money back to him. 

His generosity to her and even the torrent of his words in his letters to her are, among other things, ways of keeping what he truly feels for her--passionate love--abstract, sublimated and at a distance. In line with that, he praises and promotes the genius of his neighbour who writes terrible, purple prose filled romantic novels. He sends Varvara small quotes from them, but she tells him to stop being a fool and sends him better books to improve his literary education. But being an abstracted romantic, Makar demands virtuous characters and happy endings. His drinking manifests what in him makes him want to escape concrete action that would show directly the truth of his feelings. In his flights into alcohol he stops all contact with her. 

In contrast, Varvara is more down to earth and practical, almost stolid and  business-like even in her feeble health, abject gloom and constant suffering. Her letters are usually shorter and to the point. Unlike Makar, she seems to have and want a life outside her letters--as noted, she continually implores him to see her--while he wants to exist in his letters and wants to avoid her living presence. Therefore, when Bykov hunts her up, pursues her and makes her an offer (marriage) that she calculates she can't refuse, she accepts it even as that will mean the end of her relationship, such as it is, with Makar. 

Bykov is the contrasting proof of Makar's personal impotence: Bykov is a man of relative action and means; he has the vitality of the country in him; he is unpoetic and unromantic; he is direct, forceful and to the point; he does not pussy foot. What he puts to Varvara is in effect a business proposition;  he tells her it's time limited and otherwise he'll marry a certain merchant's daughter. She resolves her own instability, poverty and poor health by her pragmatic agreement to marry Bykov all the while intensely sadly aware of what will become bygone.

When Makar finds out about her decision, he at first abstractly encourages it as the right thing for her to do but then in the same letter starts urging her to not marry Bykov, who, he argues, is a better match for the merchant's daughter. Again, he cannot bring himself yet to say clearly and unambiguously how he loves her and wants her to be with him. He continues to evade his deepest feelings for her. 

In the meantime, in the hurried up pace of the wedding preparations--the wedding will take place within days, Varvara becomes increasingly materialistic and has Makar running here and there on errands to do with the proper material and style for her dress and with her jewellery. 

Only in his last letter to her, after she is married and almost enroute to Bykov's place out of the city and, therefore, out of Makar's reach, does he open more fully his heart and admit to his abstractedness. 

....Ah my darling! WHY did you come to this decision? How could you bring yourself to take such a step? What have you done, have you done, have you done? Soon they will be carrying you away to the tomb; soon your beauty will have become defiled, my angel. Ah, dearest one, you are as weak as a feather. And where have I been all this time? What have I been thinking of? I have treated you merely as a forward child whose head was aching. Fool that I was, I neither saw nor understood. I have behaved as though, right or wrong, the matter was in no way my concern. Yes, I have been running about after fripperies!...

....Dearest, I could throw myself under the wheels of a passing vehicle rather than that you should go like this. By what right is it being done?... I will go with you; I will run behind your carriage if you will not take me—yes, I will run, and run so long as the power is in me, and until my breath shall have failed...

Now Makar can say such things fuelled by Varvara being beyond his reach. Now that she's gone from him, now that it is too late and there is no consequence for him, he can pathetically release himself a little from his abstracted evasions. 

But even here there is no interior full reconciliation of his true feelings:

...When you are gone, Varvara, I shall die—for certain I shall die, for my heart cannot bear this misery. I love you as I love the light of God; I love you as my own daughter; to you I have devoted my love in its entirety; only for you have I lived at all; only because you were near me have I worked and copied manuscripts and committed my views to paper under the guise of friendly letters...

The lack of reconciliation is evident in his likening of his love for Varvara to his love for "the light of God" and for his daughter, which likening mixes with the concreteness of his declaration of love as such and his admission that his "friendly letters" were a "guise," a pretext behind which he hid his complete love.